a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
thundara  ·  3330 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Of kimono and cultural appropriation

    Since that last set of threads about Yale and cultural appropriation, I've come to the conclusion that those who cry about appropriation are nothing more than racists.

I think the distinction here is that the Japanese people interviewed here do not regard the kimono as a sacred symbol, and consequently embrace it as part of the spread of culture to and from America. And of all the places that a symbol would be used respectfully, museums are at the top of that list (Especially the MFA, which the last time I went, had a gallery dedicated to the damage done by the 2011 tsunami).

I would say that racist is a harsh and unnecessary word in this context. Cultural respect has all sort of grey area, and in many cases (as I would say here) people get it wrong. I think the inverse is true as well as many people confuse accidentally insulting with purposefully discriminating, which in most cases appropriation is not.

But hey, it does makes for a funny headline: Japanese Americans counter-protest Asian Americans protesting use of Japanese symbol.