a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment
marmaduke  ·  4867 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Making Music by Livecoding
Recently I started using Overtone (a similar environment for making music). What struck me the most, from the musician's perspective is, after playing music on various 'real' instruments for the last .. 18 years, is that the process of composition using code is so so different:

- on a 'real' instrument, a lot of effort goes into intonation itself, but on the other hand it is immediate and accessible; with code, you have to design the sound, knowing what sin oscillator sounds like, but then you don't have to maintain the intonation in the same way that is necessary on a 'real' instrument.

- eh, for lack of right terms, complex musical elements, like melodies harmonies, rhythms, feel rather like natural movements (eg. running, walking, juggling) with a 'real' instrument, but with the same limitations: you can only run so fast, juggle so many balls. The code, on the other hand, has the feeling of being unnatural in a way that is disconcerting (why should I need to type (choose [1 3 7 12]) to express a certain musical idea?) and enabling (I guess you could call it a musical iron man suit?)

in the end, the contrast is similar to that of other domains where the computer mimics something real that we use (eg. files and folders).