a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by possessedcow
possessedcow  ·  4372 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: Quantum gas goes below absolute zero

I was under the impression that temperature was a measurement of the movement of particles and, as such, a temperature below absolute zero was impossible by definition. The article didn't really clarify what a temperature below absolute zero entailed (or, in fact, how it was measured). Can anyone shed some light on either of these for me?





thundara  ·  4371 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Temperature has a lot of different definitions. It can be the average kinetic energy of the particles of a system, or the change in heat with respect to the change in entropy (This can be derived through both thermodynamic and statistical analysis).

In the paper, they arrive at their conclusion of "negative temperature" by manipulating the distribution of energy, such that the particles are more likely to occur at higher energies. Normally, this distribution would only be transient, and the crystal lattice of particles they had set up would collapse, eventually giving the distribution on the left side of that image. However, through some strange quantum magic that I do not understand, they managed to keep that energy distribution stable.

In the last paragraph of the publication, they give a short comment that the relevance of these temperature definitions is still being investigated:

    In ultracold quantum gases, the basic concepts of thermodynamics, positive or negative temperature, or whether a temperature concept is even relevant, are under intense and profound exploration.

If you want to read the actual publication and need past the paywall, PM me.

ButterflyEffect  ·  4371 days ago  ·  link  ·  

A temperature below absolute zero results in entropy being reduced with the addition of energy to the system. I only understand the basics when it comes to "negative temperatures", unfortunately.

It was most likely measured using a mathematical definition for temperature, such as T= (1/T) = dS/dE. Where dS is the rate of change of entropy and dE is the rate of change of energy.