Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking. Login or Take a Tour!
hittip · 4604 days ago · link · · parent · post: Happy Birthday to one of the greatest minds the world has ever known...
One of my thesis papers in college was on the Political and Socioeconomic similarities between TJ and Marx; I took the ten presumed points of a communist revolution that Marx details in The Manifesto and (IMO) showed that Jefferson would have agreed with 7 of them, mildly disagreed with two, and only outright hated one (the creation of a national bank, which obviously he hated because Hamilton was a lousy person and the control would've been in the hands of the bourgeoisie and not the proletariat). Anyway, long story short, I've been enamored with Jefferson and his awesomeness ever since.
thenewgreen · 4604 days ago · link ·
I'd be interested to read that. If you are open to sharing it, you should post it here I'm sure others would enjoy it too. I think it was b_b that once made the point that calling something "communist" because it resembles "one" of the tenants Marx put forth is disingenuous and misleading. I always appreciated that b_b, I think it was in response to a hootsbox discussion.
–
This post, a pretty good, but slightly vitriolic discussion on the nature of capitalism and Jefferson. Sometimes the Founding Fathers become like gods; we all read their words and apply our own wisdom and interpret what they said to match our current ideology. There's no objective reading of history.
–
thenewgreen · 4604 days ago · link ·
Yes. There it is:
- As to the Marx comparison, there are 10 pillars of communism. Progressive income tax is one, but it does not exist in a vacuum. To say that advocating a progressive income tax is akin to Marxism is very much along the lines of saying that anyone who thinks murder is wrong is Jewish, since Moses forbade it.