a thoughtful web.
Good ideas and conversation. No ads, no tracking.   Login or Take a Tour!
comment by DanQ
DanQ  ·  4336 days ago  ·  link  ·    ·  parent  ·  post: More people need to support fb.com/welcometohubski!

Ah! It's not so exciting. Here's the short version:

1. I have an unusual name.

2. Facebook introduce their "real names" policy.

3. Several months pass.

4. I can't log in to Facebook any more. I get a badly-formatted error message about how Facebook is a community where people use their real names.

5. I'm given the option to upload scans of government issued ID. I send my driving license.

(My account still shows as active to my friends, but any messages they send to me just disappear into a black hole. I am a Facebook non-person.)

6. Several weeks pass.

7. I reply to the auto-response email I got from them, asking how long it's likely to take.

8. Several days pass. I re-send my email.

9. Another day passes. Somebody from Facebook responds to reiterate their requirements (government issued photographic ID). I reply to say that that's exactly what I sent them. I try to log in to Facebook again, to try to submit something else, but their form now won't let me (it says that because I've already submitted ID, I now have to wait).

10. Somebody from Facebook responds by email with the same prefab response again. I email back, including a scan of my driving license AND a scan of my passport.

11. I get another email, telling me that my name is unacceptable because "Facebook is a community where people use their real names." Apparently my name isn't real enough for them. So now my account's been closed.

Fuck 'em. The good news is: I don't actually miss it. I was angry for a while, but I actually seem to be doing fine without it (I didn't use it often as it was: just logged in once every few weeks to see what was new).

As a developer, I keep a Facebook account (with no friends) so I can test Facebook integration ("Like" buttons, etc.) on websites I build. But, of course, that one's a fake Facebook account and doesn't use my name. So, ironically: Facebook banning me for using a fake name (when I wasn't) has ended up with me only having a Facebook account with a fake name.

tl;dr: Facebook introduced their "real names" policy, and decided that my name wasn't real enough for them, even when I proved that is was real enough for Her Majesty's Government.





BLOB_CASTLE  ·  4335 days ago  ·  link  ·  

If you don't mind my asking, what is so unusual about you're name?

DanQ  ·  4335 days ago  ·  link  ·  

My surname has only a single letter.

At least, I assume that's the reason that Facebook didn't think that it was real. Maybe it's that they don't believe that my first name is really "Dan", but I doubt it.

BLOB_CASTLE  ·  4335 days ago  ·  link  ·  

That's crazy. Where does your family come from that "Q" is your last name? Or did you change it (like Kim Dotcom)?

DanQ  ·  4334 days ago  ·  link  ·  

I wasn't born with this surname, no. My then-partner and I changed our surnames by deeds poll. We'd always wanted to share a family name, but didn't feel that marriage was for us, and we wanted something quirky and unique and "ours". We'd talked about it for years, until one day I suggested the possibility of a single-character surname (knowing that this would reduce the options to just 26 and thus potentially expediate the decision-making process). My blog post announcing the change.

Since then, I've run a website, freedeedpoll.org.uk, which aims to help people (in the UK) to change their name by deed poll without expense nor a solicitor: you just fill in a form, print a PDF, sign it, and you're done.

My name's caused me a couple of problems over the last six years or so that I've had it (for example, I always get stopped by Immigration Control when I travel, because they don't believe my passport is real - I try to explain every time that if I were going to make a fake passport, I'd pick a more-believable name!), but it's not been too troublesome except with Facebook. Sometimes I'm in computer databases as QQ or Qu or QQQ or Q', in order to get around short-sighted character limitations, but that's not a big problem either. My ex- and I split up, but I keep the name (mostly because it feels like it's "mine") and she's kept it too (mostly because she's too lazy to change it, I believe). But as far as I know, we're the only two people legally-known as "Q" in the world.

BLOB_CASTLE  ·  4334 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Wow, that's quite a story.

    knowing that this would reduce the options to just 26 and thus potentially expediate the decision-making process
    if I were going to make a fake passport, I'd pick a more-believable name!
Both of these made me laugh.

I hope in your future travels you meat more understanding people!

lil  ·  4335 days ago  ·  link  ·  

Welcome to hubski, Dan Q. I've never been on FB...while I suppose it's nice to know what your friends and "friends" are up to on FB, on Hubski you can find out what people you've never met are up to -- and if you are really interested in what your friends are up to, you can still email them. win win all round.

thenewgreen  ·  4335 days ago  ·  link  ·  

...and sometimes, when you're lucky those random strangers become your friend.